Lower in financial progress not a shock – economists

In one other setback for South Africa, financial progress was dragged decrease by agriculture, business and decrease funding.

The lower in financial progress of 0.2% for the third quarter didn’t come as a shock, economists say, though it was worse than anticipated after two consecutive quarters of progress. What was stunning was the nosedive in agriculture, which contracted by 9.6%.

“The stop-and-go South African financial system is undermined by quite a few supply-side constrains, whereas an more and more onerous enterprise surroundings erodes profitability. Home demand stays delicate as households cope with excessive rates of interest and elevated inflation. Circumstances are usually not anticipated to get a lot simpler over the close to time period,” Jee-A van der Linde, senior economist at Oxford Economics Africa, says.

“The end result was barely worse than our expectation of 0.1% quarter-on-quarter progress, however the lower didn’t come as a shock as we famous that the percentages of a quarterly contraction have been excessive.”

He says knowledge releases over the subsequent few weeks will present worthwhile perception into whether or not the home financial system may enter a recession within the fourth quarter, however it’s nonetheless too early to say at this stage.

“It’s definitely potential as port congestion and cargo shedding have worsened significantly. Except for the unexpected components that knocked agriculture, many of the prevailing financial weak spot is of an idiosyncratic nature.”

ALSO READ: Surprising gross home product lower in third quarter

Financial progress revised down for 2023

Van der Linde says the newest contraction in general gross home product (GDP) implies that the South African financial system is more likely to develop by 0.6% in 2023, in comparison with the earlier forecast of 0.8%. “As well as, given the supply-side constrains and weak demand, progress will stay sluggish, with actual GDP progress anticipated to come back in at round 0.8% in 2024.”

GDP within the third quarter stays little modified from the pre-pandemic ranges of the primary quarter of 2020, indicating that the South African financial system has not likely gone wherever within the final three years and that’s not anticipated to alter within the close to time period, he says.

“We forecast actual GDP to develop by about 1.2% per yr between 2023 and 2027, solely marginally greater than the 1.0% common of the 5 years earlier than the pandemic.

Reza Hendrickse, portfolio supervisor at PPS Investments, says the first in addition to the secondary sector each contracted, whereas companies skilled modest progress. Mining and agricultural output additionally declined, weighing on the first sector. The secondary sector was affected by weaker manufacturing output and development.

“The expansion surroundings in South Africa stays constrained, as current PMI knowledge indicated. Though progress continues to be unimpressive, it’s price declaring that progress managed to exceed expectations in most quarters throughout current years. We even managed to ship muted progress regardless of 2023 being the worst load shedding yr on file and regardless of quite a few different challenges.”

ALSO READ: GDP knowledge exhibits financial system nonetheless recovering, however no excellent news

Extra unfavourable than optimistic in financial progress

Prof. Raymond Parsons, NWU Enterprise Faculty economist, agrees that the decline in GDP progress was worse than anticipated, with unfavourable components clearly dominating the optimistic ones to a larger extent than anticipated.

“Though there was a short lived enchancment in vitality availability, a number of different key high-frequency indices on the time already warned of a lack of financial momentum. Comparable financial traits are more likely to additionally prevail in shaping a possible weak GDP progress final result within the fourth quarter.”

Parsons warns that the decline in fastened capital formation can be a purple flag. “The yr is more likely to finish with muted financial exercise. South Africa should now avert the potential of a technical recession, which occurs when there are two consecutive quarters of unfavourable progress.”

Other than different international and home headwinds, Parsons warns that progress expectations stay closely dependent, particularly, on phasing out load shedding, with the bottlenecks in Transnet’s rail and port companies including heavy extra prices to the financial system.

ALSO READ: Economist warns financial winter is coming in 2024

Impact of issues in logistics precipitated decrease financial progress

Goerge Herman, chief funding officer at Citadel, factors out the pervasive impression of South Africa’s faltering transport and logistics sectors and the knock-on impact it has on the broader South African financial system.

“After the financial growth over the primary two quarters of 2023, this was a actuality examine. Whereas financial contraction is rarely welcome, it is very important do not forget that these figures are backward-looking, and in gentle of the mix of load shedding and excessive rates of interest, this consequence was not sudden.”

Herman says the important thing takeaway from the GDP figures is that we should get our transport and logistics sectors working. “This isn’t solely restricted to the backlogs on the ports and borders however all through our financial system as highway freight volumes have been additionally down.

“Wanting on the family knowledge, strained customers in the reduction of on consumption expenditure for a second consecutive quarter, lowering their spending on gadgets resembling transport, recreation and housing utilities.”

ALSO READ: The way to repair Transnet’s ports within the curiosity of financial progress

Decline in agricultural GDP was a shock

Paul Makube, senior agricultural economist at FNB Business, says regardless of a number of the earlier indicators pointing to a possible upswing in agriculture GDP, the sector stunned on the draw back with the most important and sharpest contraction, underpinned by a slowdown in financial exercise for subject crops, animal merchandise and horticulture merchandise.

“Nonetheless, the majority of the bumper harvest of the 2023 summer season crops occurred within the third quarter, however the downbeat costs offset what might have been a superb quarter. The full summer season crop harvest was large at 20.74 million tons which is 6.8% greater year-on-year, with South Africa’s largest staple at 17.06 million tons and 6% greater in comparison with a yr in the past. Soybeans have been up 24% at a file excessive of two.76 million tons.”

He notes that there was a unfavourable value progress for beef and pork, with poultry principally flat whereas general livestock slaughter fell by 8% relative to the earlier quarter. The livestock subsector additionally grappled with illness outbreaks resembling avian influenza within the poultry business, and given its sheer measurement of 42% of complete agriculture gross producer worth, any decline within the subsector exercise makes an enormous dent in general agriculture progress.

“Agriculture exports had a formidable efficiency, with the worth of export earnings leaping by 4% year-on-year to US$3.9 billion. Maize continued to take pleasure in robust progress in exports, with a formidable 8.5% year-on-year surge in volumes exported at 1.64 million tons, dominated by yellow maize (81%) adopted by white maize (19%), in line with the South African Grain Data Companies (SAGIS) knowledge.”

Leave a Comment